Avoid self-publishing companies that won’t put their fees, royalty calculations, rights, and deliverables in writing. Walk away from offers that guarantee bestseller status or demand payment before you can review the contract. A company can legitimately charge for editing, design, or publishing support. You should still be able to tell what you’re buying, how you’ll be paid, and what you can take with you if you leave.
If you’re searching for self-publishing companies to avoid, use the contract to test the offer. Ask the provider to show you how one sale is calculated, where the book will be orderable, and what happens if you cancel. Those answers will tell you more than a package name or a polished sales presentation.
Royalties you can’t calculate from the contract
“Earn 80% royalties” means little until you know what the percentage applies to. Ask whether it’s based on list price, what the retailer remits, or what’s left after the provider deducts expenses. For example, if a $20 book brings in $10 from a retailer and the contract allows another $2 deduction, an 80% royalty on the remaining $8 pays $6.40. The advertised percentage alone doesn’t tell you what you’ll receive.
Ask for a worked example for each format and sales channel, plus a sample royalty statement. Check whether it shows copies sold, returns, deductions, and the amount due. If the provider collects money on your behalf, ask when it pays you and how you can verify the figures. The Authors Guild’s model trade book contract is a useful reference for what detailed reporting can look like.
Rights clauses that go beyond the job
A company hired to format a paperback needs permission to work with the files. Ask why it would also need exclusive rights to your ebook, audiobook, translation, or future books. Read the rights clause alongside the termination clause. Even if the contract says you retain copyright, a broad exclusive license can limit where and how you publish while the agreement is in force.
Ask what happens when the relationship ends. Who can take down the listing? Will the company deliver the final files and any editable source files included in the agreement? Who controls the publishing accounts and the ISBN? If rights were granted, find out how and when they return to you. Avoid an exit clause that gives you permission to leave without explaining what happens to the book.
A package price that leaves out required costs
Ask for an itemized quote showing what it costs to get the book live and what you might pay afterward. Look for required author-copy purchases, extra revision rounds, annual fees, or charges to update files and withdraw the title. If the company offers a refund, check what portion is refundable and how that changes once work begins. Writer Beware identifies undisclosed or compulsory charges as warning signs to investigate.
An all-inclusive package should name its deliverables. “Professional editing” could mean a proofread or a full developmental edit. “Marketing support” could mean a single announcement or a campaign with a defined budget and schedule. When comparing book publishing services, ask each provider to price the same work. A lower starting price can cost more if necessary tasks are billed separately.
Distribution promises that confuse availability with placement
A book can be listed on a retailer’s website, available to order through a wholesaler, or stocked in a physical store. Those are three different outcomes. IngramSpark, for example, explains that it sends book information to retailers and libraries so buyers can order through Ingram. The listing gives those buyers an ordering route; it doesn’t commit them to purchasing the book.
If a company promises “nationwide bookstore distribution,” ask for the distributor’s name and what the contract requires the company to do. Will it submit the title to a catalog, pitch it to buyers, or arrange confirmed orders? One of the practical challenges in the book publishing market is getting buyers to choose a title they can already order. Pay for a defined service you can verify.
Guarantees, pressure, and unverified affiliations
A provider can commit to delivering a cover by an agreed date or running ads with a specified budget. Be wary if it guarantees bestseller status, a minimum number of sales, or a film deal. The Authors Guild advises authors to scrutinize unsolicited offers and verify who’s behind them. If someone claims to represent a publisher or platform, confirm through contact details you find independently.
If you’re wondering “Is Amazon Publishing legit?”, separate the names. Amazon Publishing is a publisher with its own imprints. Kindle Direct Publishing, or KDP, is Amazon’s self-publishing platform. An outside company can charge for helping you prepare or upload a book, but an offer mentioning Amazon doesn’t establish an affiliation. KDP publishes its own guidance on spotting impersonators.
Contract checklist before you sign
- I know the total required cost, which extras are optional, and what triggers additional charges.
- I can calculate earnings on a sample sale and verify them against a royalty statement.
- The contract specifies the rights granted, their duration, and how I can end the agreement.
- I know who controls the ISBN, platform accounts, listings, and files after the work ends.
- The distribution clause says what the provider will do and distinguishes orderability from confirmed placement.
- The written agreement matches the sales pitch, including deadlines, refunds, and marketing deliverables.
When comparing self-publishing vs. traditional publishing, start by identifying who pays for production, who acts as the publisher, and which rights the contract grants. If you’re weighing hybrid publishing vs. self-publishing, compare the offer with the Independent Book Publishers Association’s criteria for hybrid publishers. Some authors only need a few defined services alongside self-publishing platforms for authors, where they can manage their own accounts. Ask for missing terms in writing and have a publishing attorney review any agreement that grants broad rights or requires a substantial payment.
Frequently asked questions
Is a self-publishing company a scam if it charges upfront?
No. Paying for editing, design, or production can be legitimate. The concern is an unclear fee, compulsory purchases that weren’t disclosed, or pressure to pay before you can see what the contract includes.
What is the biggest red flag in a publishing contract?
A mismatch between the sales pitch and the written terms. If the salesperson says you can leave anytime but the contract grants exclusive rights with no workable exit, ask for the agreement to be corrected before you sign.
How can I verify a company’s distribution claims?
Ask for the distributor’s name and a sample title you can look up independently. Confirm whether the title is listed online, available for wholesale order, or physically stocked. One doesn’t prove the others.
What if the company won’t show me a sample royalty statement?
Ask for a redacted sample or a written example that shows the calculation, deductions, and payment schedule. If the company will collect your sales revenue and still can’t explain what you’ll receive, don’t rely on the advertised percentage.
Can I publish on Amazon without hiring a company?
Yes. You can publish directly through Amazon KDP. You may still choose to hire help with editing, design, or formatting, but a third-party publishing package isn’t required to use KDP.
What should I do if I already signed a questionable agreement?
Gather the signed contract, invoices, sales messages, and royalty statements. Check the cancellation terms, then get legal advice before taking down the book or republishing it elsewhere. If you suspect impersonation, verify the offer through the real organization’s official support channel.


